More on Huger Foote using M6 [corrected]

greenspun.com : LUSENET : Leica Photography : One Thread

Here is an example of the type of photo that I think may be more difficult to visualize with an M6 than with an SLR, as suggested in the recent thread on Huger Foote using the M6:

While I could more or less visualize the out-of-focus area behind the plane of focus, I think its very difficult to visualize the large out-of-focus area at the bottom of the photo in front of the plane of focus. I would think that the effect of this image would be easier to see through a SLR. With an M6, one has to just shoot and then see how things come out on the slide tray. Huger Foote has many photos of this type in his book _My_Friend_from_Memphis_.

I am interested in these type of photos that depend on the relationship between the bokeh in front and behind the plane of focus to the areas that are in focus. I used an M-75/1.4 probably at f/2.

--Mitch/Bangkok

-- Mitch Alland (malland@mac.com), January 06, 2002

Answers

When I try to view this page, my image doesn't load. If you have the same problem you can see the photo at:

http://www.photo.net/photodb/photo?photo_id=508774

--Mitch/Bangkok

-- Mitch Alland (malland@mac.com), January 06, 2002.


Mitch,

Although your image still isn't displaying in my browser for some reason (Netscape 6.1), I did look at the image by scooping the URL from the page source. While I understand your point, I'm not sure that I'd get a better visualization of that scene with an SLR. At least to my eye, the pattern on the SLR's focusing screen (micro-prism with split image on mine) is enough to disrupt any real sense of the DOF when near wide open. Stopped down, it's usually too dark for me to see much.

For me, mentally visualizing the foreground would actually be easier than the background (just squint a bit). In your shot, which I like, dropping to 1.4 might have been even better, causing the focused mid-ground flowers to "pop" more from the background. It is a rather subjective area, though.

In y

-- Ralph Barker (rbarker@pacbell.net), January 06, 2002.


The reason the image isn't displaying is because the URL links to the photo.net page which holds the medium sized image, not to the image itself. Go to the photo you wish to display, right click, choose "copy image location," then use that URL when trying to display the image here.

This should be Mitch's image:

My response to the question is essentially the same as Ralph's.

-- Mike Dixon (mike@mikedixonphotography.com), January 06, 2002.


Moderation questions? read the FAQ