Film Scanner vs Flat Bed

greenspun.com : LUSENET : Leica Photography : One Thread

I have been using a good quality hp flat bed scanner to scan images for my upcoming website. I have also been saving for a film scanner with the belief that I will get better results. Is this correct? In the interim, any tips for using a flat bed scanner? thanks guys

-- Charles Curry-Hyde (charles@chho.com.au), April 01, 2001

Answers

I've done a lot of study on this issue lately myself and have come up with these answers. If money is a factor (and we're all broke after buying all our Leica gear), get the film scanner. There are some real great scanners in the $2000 - $4000 range (though these prices are Canadian)that will give excellent scans. But, as I've mentioned before, the Agfa Duo-Scans are the proverbial cats pajamas (shows how old I am). I too do a lot of scanning of relection copy and need a flat bed. I figured the only way would be to have both and then a friend the graphic trade clued me into the Agfa. They start at $1200, but to get real good scans off of 35mm you need the Hi-D model or the 2500, at $3500 and $7500 repectively. But in an impartial test of scanners in a graphics trade mag last year, the Agfa 2500 'outscanned' a number of drum scanners in the $15000 dollar and up range. As has been noted before, the Agfa uses what is called 'twin plate' technology to scan directly though a neg or trany instead of the usual flatbed way of bouncing the light of the lid of the maching, thus killing contrast mainly, but also sharpness. I went for the Hi-D and have gotten impressive 13X19 prints from the 70 meg file the scanner gave me. As well I have had some negs written from some of my scans, and the darkroom prints are indistinguisable from original neg. Check them out.

-- Bob Todrick (bobtodrick@yahoo.com), April 01, 2001.

Do you plan on using the scanner for anything other than website, such as creating files for printing 8x10 or larger? If so, currently the resolution of film scanners is advantageous.

-- Jay (infinitydt@aol.com), April 01, 2001.

Jay - i want to use it to make contact sheets, trial pictures before printing, print snap shots up to 5x7 and store a digital record of my pictures. This is an attempt to cut down on printing costs as I don't have a darkroom (or the time to print). thanks charles

-- Charles Curry-Hyde (charles@chho.com.au), April 05, 2001.

thanks for the feedback - I have subsequently found great basic info on http://www.scantips.com/faq2.html

-- Charles Curry-Hyde (charles@chho.com.au), April 05, 2001.

Moderation questions? read the FAQ