Hi, I was quite positive that I have read something about this lens but I just can't seem to find that thread, so pls do forgive me for asking again. Is the Summitar (collapsible) an ok lens to use? I am not looking for large enlargements, for that I have a modern Summicron. It is coated, perhaps only single coat? Does it compare favourably with a 50/2.8 Elma LTM? The reason I ask is that I've been offered one in great condition for a very decent sum. Thanks in advance.

-- Steven Fong (steven@ima.org.sg), December 19, 2000

Answers

I used to have both the collapsible Summicron and the Summitar. I didn't have a preference for either at the time--they both seemed to do the job. As I remember, the main irritation of the Summitar was its lack of click-stops. I'd say as an under-the-jacket backup to your modern Summicron it would be ideal, and if you don't buy it, lt me know :-)

-- Michael Darnton (mdarnton@hotmail.com), December 19, 2000.

This lens doesn't have the snap of the newer lenses, or the color saturation. It is very flattering for people shots.

-- Andrew Schank (aschank@flash.net), December 20, 2000.

Here's something interesting. I have a Summitar that I was using on my M6. Until one day, my backpack zipper broke and the m6 fell out and got run over by a car. The lens got jammed up, but after a camera repair place took it apart and put it back together, it worked once again. It's a little loose in the collapsed position, but takes great photos still. Tough lens.

Yeah, it doesn't have the "pop" of the newer lenses. And it's contrast is noticable lower than my new voigtlanders. But it's a good lens nonetheless.

-- Josh Root (rootj@att.net), December 20, 2000.

Thanks for the quick response. The truth is I already have a Summicron, which I love, and a Summilux, which I use a lot, I really should not 'need' another 50. But I just love the way it feels in my hands and how small it is when collapse that I 'lust' after it. I am by no means a collector, not having the financial disposition to be one, but I suppose this will be the first purchase solely for sentimental reasons. So Michael, I am taking it, sorry. And it is comforting to know, Josh, that this lens is tough as nut. I will also heed Andrew's advice and use it for people shots. Once again, thanks for the feedback.

-- Steven Fong (steven@ima.org.sg), December 22, 2000.