Repairing shutters..is it worth the troublegreenspun.com : LUSENET : Large format photography : One Thread
Hello Everyone, I've noticed on Ebay etc. that a person can acquire literature on the servicing of various shutters. I enjoy tinkering with anything new and I was seeking your opinions. Is it is worth trying to clean and service shutters myself or is this a "can of worms" better left unopened? Thanks for your thoughts.
-- GreyWolf (firstname.lastname@example.org), July 25, 2000
Depends on the shutter.
Ive personally clean up:
A Rapax for a 135mm on my Crown Graphic (not closing all the way on the slow speeds cleaning of the slow speed gears)
An Ilex #3 (firing at the fastest speed on all settings cleaning of the slow speed gears)
and a Dial set Compound for a Tuner Reich TC (firing at the fastest speed on all settings un freezing and cleaning of the regulating piston).
In each case, Ive very happy that I did I saved some money on a CLA. The insides of these three shutters are not as scary as I thought. On the other hand, Ive opened several Seikos on Mamiya TLR lenses, and said no thanks and put them back together! And Ive also sent a #4 Ilex off to Mr. Grimes for a CLA, due to its particular type of problem.
In summary, Id say that if youre mechanically inclined, its at least worth a try on the simpler classic shutters.
-- sheldon hambrick (email@example.com), July 25, 2000.
Hi Grey, I've had pretty good luck cleaning and lub-ing some of those I've picked up. For me the older stuff seems do-able. I know it has saved me a lot of money, and after timing them with the Camulet tester, I know what speeds they fire on. Good Luck
-- david clark (firstname.lastname@example.org), July 25, 2000.
I've CLA's my Seikos from my Mamiya TLR's. It's very satisfying to take a sticky shutter and hear the difference after you're done. I didn't realize until reading Sheldon's comments that this would be more complex than other shutters. What do I know? I have a bad habit of jumping too far right into things. I disassembled the Seikos because they were sticky at slow speeds, were cheaper, and I wasn't about to take apart my working Compur and Copal on my LF lenses.
-- John H. Henderson (email@example.com), July 26, 2000.
If you start playing around with shutters, don't get *anything* on the iris blades (especially oil). They are very light, and any amount of contaminant will cause them to sieze. Once gunked, I've never been able to get them effectively un-gunked. This is the voice of bitter experience!
-- Kevin Bourque (firstname.lastname@example.org), July 26, 2000.
Thanks for the all of the replies. I will be giving it careful consideration before opening my first shutter and discovering what lies within. I now will be waiting for the "proverbial cheap acquisition" before exploring, but I do look forward to the opportunity to see how a shutter functions. As the Chinese Proverb says "To know the road ahead, ask those coming back" and I thank you all again for the good information that you have provided me with.
-- GreyWolf (email@example.com), July 27, 2000.