Student critism that goes beyond immediate assignment? : LUSENET : Fiction 98 : One Thread

I have been attempting, more or less consistently, to make suggestions which would have improved my fellow student's work for me as a reader. Often the litteral intent of the assignment has been met quite well and my comments refer to something outside this. My question is: Is this exceeding polite bounds? No one has so far expressed any upset. And it is the sort of critique I would love to get in return. What do you think?

-- Web (, May 20, 1998

Moderation questions? read the FAQ