[ Post New Message | Post Reply to this One | Send Private Email to Ryuji Suzuki | Help ]

Response to Push or pull that is the question?

from Ryuji Suzuki (rsuzuki@rs.cncdsl.com)
What is your purpose of pushing or pulling? Contrast manipulation, or simply want the best image quality you can get?

HP5+, TMX and probably many other recent films tolerate overexposure and overprocessing much better than older films, including currently sold Plus-X. This is particularly so with HP5+ in XTOL or my D-76Ad, and TMX in Microphen or HC-110. I usually simply have to expose longer during printing without too much contrast adjustment, and I don't get noticeable increase in grain in highlight area. (PX needs contrast adjustment and I see much bigger grain in the sky, reflections, etc.)

I simply recommend to expose and process normally, and make necessary adjustments during printing process. It's a matter of finding the right combination of film, developer, and paper for the kind of images you are looking for.

I'm not against zone system, but I never felt like I need it except for a few exceedingly rare extreme cases.

(posted 8192 days ago)

[ Previous | Next ]