Nobody´s wrong, because everyone is entitled to an opinion :) No editing except for background colour though. Here´s the original:(posted 8547 days ago)
The "studio" was a living room with the curtains drawn, so there was a little diffuse backlighting. The only light on her face is from the candle. I metered for the face knowing that I would get a "hot" flame, but personally I don´t mind - taste differs... It was made for newspaper print and will probably end up looking terrible, but I´ll scan the result if I can.