Leaderboard Issue - I'm calling a "showdown"(i.e. vote)

I'd like to call TIMEOUT and plead that we should decide this with a 15-day vote. Whichever has the most interest should be implemented.

With each one of the issues, please tell us wheater you'll:

a. Fully Support this leaderboard idea. (3 points)

b. Half-Support the idea. (2 points)

c. Hate the idea, but will live with it(i.e. you'll stay) (1 point)

d. Hate the idea and leave MARP if it goes through. (0 points)

We can change the point values if you wish.

With each idea, if you vote A - C, I think you should mention any changes that should occur. Ideas proposed are:

1. Keep the leaderboard as it is.

2. Go back to a 10-3-1 system(or similar)

3. A tie is a tie is a tie - everyone gets same points.

4. If there's tie, the faster one gets greater points.

5. Have a cutoff(mention what it should be if you're A - C on this idea)

6. Give out points for a certain place(in the current instance, 3rd) or better regardless of the cutoff line.

7. Use the tournament rules(1st = number of recordings, 2nd = number of recordings - 1, last = 1 point)

8. Throw out the leaderboard all together.

9. Limit the number of recordings / day

Any other ideas?

My votes:

1. A

2. C(with the population, if we had to go with this, let's do 5th or better scores)

3. A

4. C

5. B(I think either 5 or 10 points are good.)

6. A(I think it should be 5th or better instead of 3rd.)

7. B

8. A

9. A(20 / day would be good here)

I feel like taking a test... at least we'll all get 100 % :)

[ Previous | Next ]