Hey if you can afford a Sidewinder or what ever cooky joystick you mentioned you had then you CAN afford an autofire :)(posted 9627 days ago)I vote to remove the T&F and clone scores, but notify all those players who have scores and give them a week to download their non cheating score to be able to upload it again, or maybe just send it to them via mail attachment when they are removed.
However, i think you should first vote to specify what will be allowed and what will not be allowed before cleaning the slate and have the specification of the uploads in the Description of the game, so you can avoid any confusion in filling the slate back up.