Response to DSR-PD100

For what it's worth, I haven't been able to get any additional information on the camera from the local Sony pro dealer here either. Just based on the spec sheets, here's some things to consider between the two cameras...

DSR PD100: PROS: + mini DVCAM instead of mini DV format. The record time is less--I think the max you can get on a DVCAM tapes right now is about 40ish minutes--but you get a more durable tape format with locked audio. + is much less obstrusive if you are doing documentary work and want to be inconspicuous. + fold out LCD display looks nice + XLR jack is included with the camera (the XL1 requires the xlr adapter accessory, which is pretty much a must have accessory for the Canon) + comes with the wide-angle adapter

CONS: - specs looked like the 3 chips were smaller than the VX1000 and more like the TRV9000. If that's the case, my guess is that the picture quality will be better on the VX1000 and even better on the XL1. - small size and form factor will make it difficult to get steady handheld shots - only one XLR input I saw (Canon has two with the adapter, as does the VX1000 with the Beach Tec xlr adapter) - the wide angle lens adapter is nice, but not a ton of other lens options - the consumer camcorder look of the camera could be a disadvantage if you WANT to have the "big camera pro" look. - it looks like the controls won't allow for easy adjustment of many settings on the fly while shooting

XL1: + terrific image quality + ergonic design that makes it easy to change the exposure, shutter speed, gain, white balance, and line input levels while shooting + ability to use the Canon EOS lenses with the addition of an adapter ($450). Aside from getting terrific glass this way, you also get the ability to do marked / rack focusing; very handy for most staged shots and not really possible on the VX1000 or probably the PD100 because of the focus servo arrangement + looks pro

CONS - camera is a bit front heavy with the lens included - some of the "accessories" really should be included with the base camera, paritcularly the dual XLR adapter/shoulder pad - servo manual focus and zoom controls can be frustrating in some shooting situations (as they are with the Sony... just share the same problem)--again, can be fixed if you get the EOS adapter, lens, etc.... but, this option can get pricey for the lens and wide angle adapter you'll be looking at. Still, it's nice to at least HAVE the option with the camera. - you're not going to be unobtrusive with this camera

Anyhow, I love my XL1. I'm thinking about getting a DSR PD100 also for when I want to go really low-profile on a shoot. I'm sure that for videography and staged filmmaking I'll stick with the XL1. Up until now the VX1000 has played the role of the unobtrusive, durable, point and shoot camera for me, but the PD 1000 should offer some nice features in this area.

Anyway, that's my two cents, -- John

[ Previous | Next ]